You should try the enhanced edition, Baldurs Gate 2 EE just came out this month, it's great, new companions, some of them romanceable (if not all, i'm not sure), some new quests, widescreen support etc.
Since I played the first episode of Wolf Among Us in every way possible (i think) i've been playing "Lego - Lord Of The Rings" XD Got it on Steam for 7,50€, didn't expect much and am very positively surprised^^
Definitely Persona 4. Aside from the obvious gameplay enhancements in P4, Persona 3 was trying too hard to be emo for my taste, the protragonist even looks like one, i could never identify with him, and since he's supposed to represent me that's no good. The P4 Protagonist seems much more...