Glad you like it. Are the words there legible? When it was still a prototype, a staff member was trying to read it though he missed some words, so I guess I succeeded in making it not very legible, teehee. And no, I would hate doing a lazy man's work for a new skin, lol.
Well, we're even, then. No need to apologise over that either, because I suppose everyone has Life™ after all.
Haha, was that guy fond of, say, using emoticons such as ;w; or c: and the like that are more often used by girls? And yes, that's correct. To be honest, I was a bit surprised the first time I saw how often C4D renders were used freely by signature makers. I mean, C4D is a field that casual designers usually stay out of. If you're an abstract artist, do 3D modelling or deal with CAD stuff, maybe. But if you're just an everyday designer whose only tool of trade is Photoshop, well, I'd say that's rather peculiar. The problem, as with all kinds of stock graphics, is as you described: if you have a good feel in mixing and matching elements, you can do good with them. Otherwise, unlikely. And no, I've made some crappy C4D-laden signatures myself that I'd rather not see again orz. I stopped using them pretty early, lol.
Nope, having opinions is all well and good, so I welcome that. As about your stuff, well, your SOTM-winning signature looks nice and harmonious, so I don't have much to add. If I had to, though, I'd say that maybe you could improve the typography: since the face of the character stands out very well, it's easily the most dominant focal point within the entire image. And the basic concept of typography, I believe, is to avoid distracting already-existing focal points with (most basically) the placement of the text. It's nice that you placed the text in an empty area so as to avoid making it look messy; I just think it kinda tries (and fails) to compete with the face as the focal point. Just my two cents, of course.