I don't think "disliked internally" is a thing - if you dislike something you just don't buy it, you don't go and try to stop other people from buying/making it. We got a lot of things that are highly disliked by a lot of people and yet immensely popular - take sports game, Battle royale, card games & etc. Even our NTR genre.
Also your hate for Scat is truly legendary :D I think if you try to let it go and try to avoid/skip scenes with it it would be better and there would be more "good" parts of the game to enjoy. I dislike a lot of things, but I just try to ignore them and focus more on stuff i like. If you just keep focusing on things you hate it will just hurt you more :(
Also if you dislike something - wishing it to fail is bad for people who like it, just let it go
Concerning
Grand Guignol no Yoru - are you sure it was a big flop? I dunno about its sales numbers, but ratings on vndb are pretty ok. Personally I wasn't that interested in that game because judging by CG gallery its just mostly ordinary human sex with few pregnancy/guro/scat scenes here and there, no monsters/tentacles or other stuff I'm interested in, maybe i ll give it a try in the future. I think its just that
Aojiru should focus more on things that he his famous for - tentacles, and that game had none of them :(
Guro i think is too often used just for the sake of it. I think its better used not just as "shock" element but as a part of atmosphere of horror, madness and depression, like a part of horror game but with sexual stuff. To think of it, Horror genre is itself not as popular as before but we do see some good titles occasionally, and i think it is already rising in popularity lately.
Lets go back to discussing NTR stuff, don't make me more depressed people
Looks good -
Bubuzuke's arts is always good and colorful.
But is it ntr? Can someone say what story page is about?