Panda
New member
- Aug 31, 2013
- 13
- 0
@FinalPyre
Interesting... Are you suggesting solipsism? Unfortunately, there's no way to refute this or to prove it. The problem is: it's not logical to assume that the only certain thing is oneself.
For example: you can't convince me of solipsism; you have only two ways to convince me:
a) I'm a projection of your imagination, which I will not believe because I am conscious (whether you believe it or not).
b) You are a projection of my imagination.
If you are a projection of my imagination-- if I am hallucinating your existence, can I really believe you? Can I really believe a hallucination? If you are a conscious being, you would be contradicting your own beliefs on solipsism, in which you would not exist. However, even if this doesn't mean that solipsism is false, it doesn't provide any practical use. If I look at it another way: my subconscious created this world, so am I my own God? (Technically: did my subconscious create this universe?)
Likewise, that would mean there is only one solipsist that is correct in each "world". Yet, if that solipsist is not me, then who is it? If solipsism is true, would that mean that I'm a projection from someone's imagination? Or, does that mean that I believe this false reality? But, who is to say that I'm living a false life? If I am indeed living a false life, everyone else is only a projection of my imagination. It seems to be more of a personal belief than a belief for practical use. It can't be tested, it can't be completely refuted, and it's not valid in science.
Interesting... Are you suggesting solipsism? Unfortunately, there's no way to refute this or to prove it. The problem is: it's not logical to assume that the only certain thing is oneself.
For example: you can't convince me of solipsism; you have only two ways to convince me:
a) I'm a projection of your imagination, which I will not believe because I am conscious (whether you believe it or not).
b) You are a projection of my imagination.
If you are a projection of my imagination-- if I am hallucinating your existence, can I really believe you? Can I really believe a hallucination? If you are a conscious being, you would be contradicting your own beliefs on solipsism, in which you would not exist. However, even if this doesn't mean that solipsism is false, it doesn't provide any practical use. If I look at it another way: my subconscious created this world, so am I my own God? (Technically: did my subconscious create this universe?)
Likewise, that would mean there is only one solipsist that is correct in each "world". Yet, if that solipsist is not me, then who is it? If solipsism is true, would that mean that I'm a projection from someone's imagination? Or, does that mean that I believe this false reality? But, who is to say that I'm living a false life? If I am indeed living a false life, everyone else is only a projection of my imagination. It seems to be more of a personal belief than a belief for practical use. It can't be tested, it can't be completely refuted, and it's not valid in science.