[MENTION=169]pyrce[/MENTION]
I really like TMGS: 1st Love Plus. Kei is definitely the best route at least to me.
If you would like some recommendations then here's a few to try:
Under 18
- The Second Reproduction (It's all right if you haven't played the prequel because they summarize the important details in a few paragraphs in this game)
- Hakuouki ~Shinsengumi Kitan~(It's in my backlog, so I'm unable to provide much detail. Still, it was one of the most anticipated otome-ge to be released in English. Many good reviews about it.)
- AMNESIA (I played some of it and the story is very mesmerizing and melancholic. A nice cast of characters and lovely graphics.)
- Ren'ai Banchou! (Quite humorous and colorful. They made the characters as farfetched as possible, but it adds to the charm.)
- Garnet Cradle (There's a PSP and PC version. The PSP version appears to have 'more content' since it's 15+. Lovely character designs and they grow on you as the story goes on.)
18+
- Akazukin to Mayoi no Mori (A dark themed story, but a good one that keeps you reading. The seiyuu were the highlight for me. The character designs were off for some parts.)
- Under the Moon or Ijiwaru MyMaster (Two different games, but the characters' personalities and game play are pretty similar. So why not let you choose between the two? xD I prefer Ijiwaru MyMaster because I find the female protagonist more tolerable and it doesn't feel like a sex-fest.) Lol~
- Riddle Garden (Depending on the route, the stories can be heart-warming and pretty memorable or just plain cliche and dull. The heroine can be annoying to some people, but there are some good scenes as well.)
- Step -Futari no Kankei wa Ippo zutsu- (This one is good for the humor and the story with a few characters. The other characters are just so-so. It's a game to try at least once.)