It might end up better without actual NTR because their plots are all generally terrible. I've only played about 9 of their titles and almost all of them so far are either mediocre or outright bad...
But the art here looks fantastic! So in the very worst case it should still be tolerable. Plus I don't know if there's anything else with this premise, so the creativity is a positive.
Well you're right that the art looks nice. But when you say "their plots are all generally terrible" are you talking about the NTR games from Atelier Sakura? Because it depends on which one's you've played, since they've only got one writer who's worth anything.
Sounds interesting.
But i'm very picky with my eroges and this one doesn't got into my list so far
I like younger girls more, being a lolicon i'm more interested in this one
http://www.getchu.com/soft.phtml?id=860682
But i have to say that i'm not a fan of games where the heroine ends up in a group sex with a lots of men, i don't really know why but doesn't attract me.
Aside lolis, high school girls and college girls are the best for me.
recently I'm into some jk gals but is not netorare so i will not comment about it here.
Also, lately, somehow i'm seeing a increase in the number of doujinshis with shotas and i don't like shotas, so sad.
I can sympathise with your strike zone there since I'm similar in that I'm not a big fan if milfs and mature ladies in ero, much prefering them to be under 30 at least, and ideally somewhere in their teens. Loli is fine too, though I generally prefer curves to pettanko. But yeah, I'm also rather tired of the abundance of shota x milf works in eromanga and even eroge these days. Though reason I mentioned that last upcoming game was because the writer is decent and good NTR games are mostly in the writing and the characters, plus they're just engaged and a young couple so she not a milf yet. And if the NTR is good enough then I can make an exception, such as with Marina. Not really gals though, I prefer girls with the naturally cute looks, girls that obviously have dyed hair, gaudy painted nails and fake tans lower my interest a bit, and the addition of excessive piercing and tattoos is actually a turn off. She doesn't have to pure as a driven snow so long as she doesn't look trashy at first glance. I don't like trashy looks in heroines in general. just my tastes though.
I have to disagree with you about netori though, not that I don't like the fetish itself, but more that the way describe it doesn't seem to quite fit with the idea of the fetish. At least you're talking about a very light idea of netori. Playing a guy who steals a girl who is being poorly treated by a guy who doesn't value her and is generally a jerk, hardly seems to count as
stealing at all in my book. More like he'd be
saving the girl from the other guy, which I can see having a satisfying kick to it. But as a fetish netori is supposed to be about beating another guy, stealing his girl out from under his nose and feeling superior from knowing that even thought she has a man, she's here letting you have your way with her instead of with him right now. It's about conquest and the immoral feeling of being bad that adds to the excitement.
But players don't want to seem to want to deal with the guilt or sympathise with a guy who's doing that kind of thing so we rarely see it done, and usually we just see crap where the protag is either a villain that the player can comfortably disassociate themselves from (usually using blackmail/mind-control to get the girls) or sometimes just a scenario about screwing around with women who happen to be housewives while avoiding showing the husbands or doing anything to make the reader feel the guy is doing something wrong, both types usually pure nukige with any kind of realistic plot developments.
If I was going to like a netori scenario, it'd have to be realistic and not have the protag as a 'good' or even a 'bad' guy, but as a more normal, easier to relate to guy. He thinks he's a good person that wouldn't do something like stealing someone else's girlfriend/wife, until the time comes when he gets the opportunity to actually do it and with a girl he'd kill to get with at any other time. When the time comes he ends up giving in to temptation and then the story shows him being torn between the guilt and self-loathing and between his lust and the immoral thrill and exhilaration of being in a cheating relation and having to face the boyfriend/husband at other times, with the danger of it being exposed. I could really get into a scenario like that if it was done well. Though I've yet to see one.