- Oct 4, 2015
- 686
- 201
Thank you so much for this wonderful early Christmas present! I mostly write here to collect my thoughts and have something to refer to when I'm trying to remember what I felt about a game, but it's always very nice to hear that someone enjoyed reading my rants.ps. Btw, I really enjoyed your reviews!
Without further ado, Amakano 2 trial impressions!... I'll start by saying I had some unexpected guests this week-end and didn't have the time to read as carefully as I would have liked, but even then the lasting impression the demo left on me after about three hours was : "Thank god, at last it's over". I'm afraid my initial worries about the heroines' setup was pretty spot-on. The game makes a big deal out of finding out the proper 距離感 (I guess you could say "distance"), but it starts all wrong.
[SPOILER="Heroines are terrible" rant]The biggest offender is by far the big sister. She is extremely clingy and very often annoying, and the whole "it's normal between siblings" excuse doesn't make one bit of sense since... they're not! And even if they were, it wouldn't be appropriate either, at least in Japan. She pets him constantly, feeds him in front of others without a care, fixes his hair or his clothing in public, cue obligatory ear cleaning sequence... and to boot she pouts when he hesitates to respond to her overwhelming attention. I'll be honest, I hate this kind of character, and the more I saw her, the more I wished she would just go away. Alas, only three heroines in this game, so that's unlikely, especially considering how close she and the protagonist are.
Next we have the robot-like cousin who seems to have never shared space with another human being before. She feels absolutely nothing sleeping in the same room (yes room, not house) as the protagonist, has no hesitations stripping in front of him, and is generally such an oddball that it's hard to take her seriously considering the previous Amakano heroines all were somewhat anchored in reality. I don't mind strange characters but this is pushing it a bit much, although I'll admit it was a bit nice to see her warm up to the protagonist... and his sister. And therein lies the problem, her views on 距離感 get completely twisted by what she sees happen between the protagonist and "big sis", which makes her visions of human rapports even more twisted than before. Before long she settles on a "little sister" position that she has no place in. I'm so tired of characters "becoming" siblings, it's not something you can decide overnight. But of course the protagonist is all too happy to be a nice little oniichan, encouraged by his beloved oneechan, and this just make me worry so much about the further developments in the relationship. We already did the little sister stuff with Kanade in ~second season~, and she was enough.
Finally we have third oddball character in the form of transfer student. ~second season~ had Honami that started the game hating the protagonist and slowly warmed up to him, she is the reverse : she starts the game pretty friendly to the protagonist but gets progressively colder, ending with what is essentially a rejection (not that he confessed mind you), claiming that she has no interest in romance with anyone. She tends to keep a lot of secret, skips classes without reasons. Her reactions to pretty common things and her overall top-class academics make me wonder if she's not a ojou-sama neglected by her parents (quite similar to Honami in that...), or if her partner is already arranged by her family and thus no interest in love and all that. The demo forces us to choose her during the map selection but I can't say I grew fond of her very much, which was clearly intentional but still.[/SPOILER]
So, heroines are a complete mess so far, and I can't find a single one I'm actually looking forward to. This can change depending on the further developments, but so far as the game progresses the further away my interest goes for them. Art-wise, Piromizu really forced the chest-size up compared to the previous entries, it's pretty unnatural especially for a certain big sis but it can be said for all three of them. Ryu Gakuru's text is as usual easy to read but with no interest in the heroines the temptation to skip climbs really, really fast. All in all, I'm not really looking forward to the game anymore, which is sad.
EDIT: I'm gonna temper what I wrote by mentioning that I generally don't play demos specifically because I tend to dislike the common route in games. I'm sure once we get into the "1 on 1" relationship it'll get much better, less of the "big sis" would be a huge relief already. This is something that was also true of the first two games, especially the second. Also, anger and frustration may or may not be related to having seen a particular movie franchise's last entry Saturday night.
Last edited: